The term 'OLD NEW YORK PAPER' can be solved by the crossword solution 'HERALD' (6 letters). The New York HERALD was a newspaper published in New York City from 1835 to 1924. It was one of the most influential American newspapers of the 19th century and was the first newspaper in New York City to have a Sunday edition. The paper was known for its sensationalism, and it was the first to report Abraham Lincoln's assassination.