My Eye! is an expression used to express surprise or disbelief. The three crossword solutions for this term are HAH (3 letters), PSHAW (5 letters), and IBET (4 letters). HAH is an interjection used to express laughter, surprise, or disbelief. PSHAW is an interjection used to express contempt or disbelief. IBET is an interjection used to express a challenge or a bet. All three of these interjections can be used to express disbelief or surprise, which is the sentiment behind the phrase My Eye!.