The term 'Like Sharp Cheddar' can be summarized by two crossword solutions: TANGY (5 letters) and AGED (4 letters). Cheddar is a type of cheese that originated in the English village of Cheddar in Somerset, England. It is a hard, off-white or orange, sometimes sharp-tasting cheese. TANGY refers to its sharp, acidic flavor, while AGED refers to the process of maturing the cheese over time to bring out its full flavor.