The term COOKIE SPICE is composed of four crossword solutions: ANISE (5 letters), NUTMEG (6 letters), OREO (4 letters), and AMOS (4 letters). ANISE is a type of herb with a licorice-like flavor, often used in baking. NUTMEG is a spice made from the seed of an evergreen tree, and is commonly used in desserts. Oreo is a brand of cookie that has been around since 1912, and is one of the most popular cookies in the world. AMOS is a brand of cookie that was first introduced in 1956, and is known for its chocolate and peanut butter flavor.